The Empty Trace

by Manon Soavi

‘Chouang Tzu, the great Chinese philosopher, said 2,500 years ago: “True human beings breathe from their heels, whereas ordinary people breathe from their throat.”

Who breathes from their heels nowadays? People breathe from their chest, their shoulders or their throat. The world is full of these invalids who ignore themselves.’1Tsuda Itsuo, The Non-Doing, Chap. I, 2013, Yume Editions (Paris), p. 15

This is how Tsuda sensei begins his first book, published in 1973, setting the tone by quoting the philosopher who most accompanied him throughout his life.

Tsuda sensei was a relentless researcher and a man of great culture. Throughout his life, he worked tirelessly to enable human beings to free themselves from what burdens and hinders them. Starting from his personal quest for freedom of thought, it was ultimately a philosophical understanding of human beings that emerged through his practices: Aikido, Seitai, Nō… And Tsuda sensei spread this philosophy of human beings, this path, primarily through his books2nine books (plus one posthumous) published in French between 1973 and 1984 – still available[ – then in English from 2013 to 2025]and his teaching in dojos over a period of ten years. But there was a more secret medium that he took up in the last years of his life: calligraphy.

L'ermite véritable, calligraphie de Itsuo Tsuda
_The true hermit_, calligraphy by Tsuda Itsuo

On this subject, he presented himself as an “amateur calligrapher” in the Zen sense, where, like many masters of martial arts, Ikebana, Chadō, etc., he used calligraphy to communicate a state of mind and convey a philosophy.

Tsuda sensei took a unique approach to calligraphy, a step aside of a sort. Due to the constraints of the time, he chose to trace with wax. A constraint that led to surpassing oneself. The ideograms are traced with hot wax using a brush, then the fabric is dyed, and finally the wax is removed. What remains is the trace, an empty trace.

The desire to express the inexpressible, to communicate what cannot be communicated3The Non-Doing (op. cit.), Foreword, p. 9

In his books, Tsuda sensei strives to make concepts and principles that often seem very distant from our culture accessible to readers. He builds bridges, talking to us about ordinary situations that reveal a much deeper background. This is what makes reading his books an enjoyable and straightforward experience.

Calligraphy is different. It is a more “esoteric” teaching, in the sense that it requires an effort of understanding on our part, to take an active part in it. Yet Tsuda sensei conveys an essential teaching for those who want to delve deeper.

It was after the age of sixty, in France, that he began tracing calligraphies and dispersing the seeds of what had nourished his journey and his history.

His story begins in 1914 in Korea, under Japanese rule, where his parents, who were members of the nobility, had settled. At the age of sixteen, he rebelled against his father’s authority and set out in search of freedom of thought. Arriving in Paris in 1934, he studied ethnology and sinology at the Sorbonne under Marcel Mauss and Marcel Granet. The war interrupted his studies and he had to return to Japan. It was only after the end of the conflict that he became more deeply interested in the cultural aspects of his country and began studying with Master Kanze Kasetsu and Seitai with Noguchi Haruchika sensei. Hired as an interpreter for André Nocquet, who had just arrived in Japan to study Aikido, he was captivated by the personality of O-sensei Ueshiba Morihei and by the art he discovered. Thus, until O-sensei’s death, he practised daily at the Hombu Dōjō in Tōkyō.

Tsuda sensei often said that the masters he had known had each dug different wells, but that at the bottom of each well flows the same water and that they communicate with each other.4The Non-Doing (op. cit.), Foreword, p. 12

So, when he returned to France in the early 1970s, he initially focused on spreading Seitai and Aikido, while beginning to write his first book. He started in 1978 to introduce his students to his calligraphies.

A vast culture

The hundred or so calligraphies he traced express an entire culture, as many of Tsuda Itsuo’s calligraphies refer to texts by Zhuangzi and Laozi, or suggest them through an ideogram or drawing. Others are Zen sayings, proverbs, or Chinese or Japanese cultural references popular at the time.

For example, the calligraphy The true hermit lives in the heart of great cities is a well-known phrase from a poem by Wang Kang-Ju (Eastern Jin dynasty, 317-420). Tsuda Itsuo quoted this text several times, notably in this passage from his book The Path of Less:

‘There is a Zen precept that says:
“The small hermit lives on a mountain. The great hermit lives in a town.”
I hear city people envy farmers who live in the countryside and breathe clean air. I also hear exasperated peasants who say: they don’t have the troubles we do.

One man’s joy is another man’s sorrow. I do not concern myself with the issue of milieu. I am only concerned with what happens inside us. If people want to become small hermits, that is their business. In any case, I am not the one who encourages them to do so because the underlying problem remains.5Tsuda Itsuo, The Path of Less, Chap. 8, 2018, Yume Editions, p. 82

In his calligraphies, Tsuda sensei refers to Buddhism, Chan, or even a poem or concept that comes directly from one of his masters: Noguchi Haruchika or Ueshiba Morihei.

A subtle humour emanates from his calligraphies, as in Circle, Triangle, Square, which is a fairly classic Zen calligraphy. Tsuda Itsuo took the name The Universe, which was given to Sengai Gibon’s calligraphy. He traced a circle, a triangle and a square, but he did so in his own way, with his unique sense of humour, a mischievous take on the precarious situation of human beings: Circle, sky. Triangle, human being. Square, earth.

trace vide
_The Universe_, calligraphy by Tsuda Itsuo

But the particular orientation of each stroke makes the calligraphy look like a little man!

The slightly twisted triangle connects a very solid base, the earth, with the head in the sky. Human beings in their imperfection, their imbalance, their humanity.

And, at the same time, human beings are Ame-no-ukihashi, the link between heaven and earth… As Tamura sensei also reported6Léo Tamaki’s blog Budo no Nayami, « Interview Tamura Nobuyoshi, l’aigle de l’Aïkido » [‘Interview Tamura Nobuyoshi the Eagle of Aikido], 27 July 2007, available online (in French), O-sensei Ueshiba Morihei often used the expression Ame no ukihashi ni tatete7[the Japanese reads most probably: 天浮橋立てて ], ‘stand on the floating bridge of heaven’.

To appreciate this world, we must take a step forward. As always, it is not just about the quality of the teacher, the greatness of the art, the quality of the book or the calligraphy. Entering into the perception to which these calligraphies invite us also depends on us; we cannot simply open our beaks like baby birds waiting to be fed, we must go hunting ourselves. ‘The […]artist has merely begun a process that is reactivated when the painting is seen, leading to various levels of communication and understanding. Because the viewer has a vital role in completing the work in his or her spirit[…]’8Stephen Addiss, The Art of Zen: Paintings and Calligraphy by Japanese Monks 1600-1925, 1989, Introduction, pub.‎ Harry N. Abrams., p. 12. [In order for the reader to appreciate how much the quoted ‘Because’ is diverted from Addiss’ intention, here is the full sentence: ‘Because the viewer has a vital role in completing the work in his or her spirit, true Zenga embodies the actual experience (rather than merely the influence) of Zen.’]. The masters have left us traces; it is up to us to follow them with diligence and continuity.

For readers who would like to explore Tsuda sensei’s calligraphic work further, a book will be published this autumn featuring around a hundred of his calligraphies, as well as research, sources and possible translations. This book takes us on a journey to the sources of the philosophy proposed by Tsuda sensei. To the sources that nourished his journey and which thereby can nourish ours.

Manon Soavi

The exhibition opening will take place in Paris to mark the publication of the book Itsuo Tsuda, Calligraphies de Printemps [Itsuo Tsuda, Spring Calligraphies] on 18 and 19 November 2017, at Tenshin dojo, 120 rue des Grands-Champs, 75020 Paris.

Would you like to hear about the next article?

Subscribe to our newsletter

Article by Manon Soavi published in October 2017 in Dragon Magazine Spécial Aikido n° 18.

Notes

  • 1
    Tsuda Itsuo, The Non-Doing, Chap. I, 2013, Yume Editions (Paris), p. 15
  • 2
    nine books (plus one posthumous) published in French between 1973 and 1984 – still available[ – then in English from 2013 to 2025]
  • 3
    The Non-Doing (op. cit.), Foreword, p. 9
  • 4
    The Non-Doing (op. cit.), Foreword, p. 12
  • 5
    Tsuda Itsuo, The Path of Less, Chap. 8, 2018, Yume Editions, p. 82
  • 6
    Léo Tamaki’s blog Budo no Nayami, « Interview Tamura Nobuyoshi, l’aigle de l’Aïkido » [‘Interview Tamura Nobuyoshi the Eagle of Aikido], 27 July 2007, available online (in French)
  • 7
    [the Japanese reads most probably: 天浮橋立てて ]
  • 8
    Stephen Addiss, The Art of Zen: Paintings and Calligraphy by Japanese Monks 1600-1925, 1989, Introduction, pub.‎ Harry N. Abrams., p. 12. [In order for the reader to appreciate how much the quoted ‘Because’ is diverted from Addiss’ intention, here is the full sentence: ‘Because the viewer has a vital role in completing the work in his or her spirit, true Zenga embodies the actual experience (rather than merely the influence) of Zen.’]